Opinion Editorial Archive October, 2020: Could We Start Again?

opinion editorial
Any opinions expressed do not necessarily represent the policies of The Peoples of the World Foundation. Unless otherwise noted, the author and photographer is Dr. Ray Waddington.

Stock licensing available.

In May, 1893 the World's Fair was held in Chicago. The telephone had existed for only a few years and the most promising use of electricity appeared to be for lighting; the high cost made that a novelty for the wealthy. The fair needed a huge (for the time) supply of electricity and, as is often the case with technology, there were competing standards. In the end Westinghouse Electric and the alternating current standard won the bid to supply that electricity. By then it had become clear that electricity would play an important part in people's lives one day. Plans were already in place to further harness the power of Niagara Falls for hydroelectric generation on a much larger scale than existed there. In the same year, the major part of that contract also went to Westinghouse. That sealed the fate of the alternating current standard and it has been the global standard for long-distance electricity distribution ever since.

In the context of this history, a little-reported news story caught my attention last month. Dunnadi Asthan is a small, remote village in the Indian Himalayan State of Jammu and Kashmir. It has just been electrified.

It should not surprise us that it took over a hundred years for electricity to reach this small village. After all, writing has existed for five thousand years, yet many languages that are spoken today still cannot be written. Most of those are indigenous languages. Umpithamu is not one of them because it shares its fate with 95% of Australia's other indigenous languages — it is no longer spoken, its last speaker having died eight years ago. Even though it is now extinct, just a few days ago the first dictionary in that language was completed. Likewise, many of the places still without electricity are indigenous villages.

The lady in this month's photo may have distant relatives in Dunnadi Asthan since parts of Nepal (where the photo was taken, in Bhaktapur) were populated by migration from Jammu and Kashmir. In any case, she was born at a time when her small village (which Bhaktapur was at the time) had no electricity. When I come across people like her in places like this, I sometimes reflect on the changes they must have seen during their life. Even more interesting is the opinions they might hold about the consequences of those changes. Are they likely to look back and ask: 'Could we start again, please?' as Jesus's followers lament in the stage musical, Jesus Christ Superstar?

It's even less common to witness the very beginning of the kind of changes now about to take place in Dunnadi Asthan. It is mainly populated with ethnic Bakerwals, Gujjars and Paharis. The fact that they have lived peacefully alongside each other for centuries is a reflection of what we see in the paleoanthropological record: despite incidences of inter-tribal warfare, differing societies have, for the most part, lived together successfully throughout history. With electricity, these people are about to learn of the turmoil their part of the world faces. I was in Jammu and Kashmir, and not far from Dunnadi Asthan, two winters ago. A few days previously there had been a major terrorist attack amid the ongoing border dispute with Pakistan. Already it felt like a war zone. Now the region is seeing a border dispute with China also.

It could be debated whether writing or electricity has had the greater impact on human societies. Yet it is clear that the two technologies combined have changed us forever. Even clearer is that their combination in the form of social media has the potential to divide and create conflict among our differing societies more than anything ever has. By the time that happens in Dunnadi Asthan, the people there will likely be asking: 'Could we start again, please?' The irony of the number in Superstar is that Jesus's followers (who had neither writing nor electricity) are unaware that it is too late to start again. We don't have that excuse. The 'Climate Clock' in New York City last week told us we have seven years. Perhaps a coincidence, the day after that clock was taken down, the Leaders' Pledge for Nature was launched with the aim of reversing biodiversity loss in the next ten years. There have been similar, but failed, initiatives before. So far only a third of the world's countries have signed the pledge — with the usual suspects absent. Tellingly, only one indigenous peoples organization formally supports the pledge at the time of writing. Yet this may truly be our last chance to start again.

If you enjoyed reading this month's opinion editorial, please consider supporting independent, advertising-free journalism by buying us a coffee to help us cover the cost of hosting our web site. Please click on the link or scan the QR code. Thanks!
Buy us a coffee QR

Stock licensing on Alamy. Follow us on Twitter. Subscribe to our Youtube channel.

© The Peoples of the World Foundation and individual contributors, 1999 - 2023. All rights reserved.

Pages with embedded videos may use third-party cookies. Otherwise our website does not use cookies or any other kind of tracking technology.